Is the modern toothbrush a substitute for the miswaak?
Using A Toothbrush As A Substitute For The Miswaak
Question
Answer
The toothbrush cannot replace a Miswaak. With regards to cleaning the mouth, there are two Sunnats, one is to use the specific stick (Miswaak), and the other Sunnat is to clean the mouth. If a person doesn’t have a Miswaak then if a person uses a toothbrush or his finger with the intention of a replacement, then in this case, he will get the reward of cleaning the mouth but will not get the reward of using the Miswaak.
Checked and Approved By:
Mufti Muhammed Saeed Motara Saheb D.B.
References
ولا يقوم الاصبع مقام الخشبة فان لمم توجد الخشبة فحينئذ يقوم الاصبع من يمينه مقام الخشبة كذا في المحيط و الظهيرية
(الفتاوى الهندية ج١ ص ٦)
وتقوم الاصبع او الخرقة الخشبة مقامه عند فقده او عدم اسنانه في تحصيل الثواب لا عند وجوده
( البحر الرائق ج١ ص ٢١)
فتح القدير ج ١ ص ٢٥
حلبى كبير ص ٣٣
حاشية الطحطاوى على الدر ج١ص ٧٠
رد الحتار ج ١ ص ١١٥
Related Fatawa
When To Do Khilaal Of The Toes
Question Is khilal of the toes with the little finger of the left hand before or after washing the feet? Read more
Part Of The Hand To Use For Masah Of The Neck
Question Is Masah of the neck with the back of the fingers or the back part of the hand? Answer Read more
Method Of Masah Of The Head
Question I have heard of 2 procedures for Masah of the head: First is to pass all 4 fingers over the head Read more
Wetting The Hand For Masah
Question When it comes to Masah of the head, do both the hands as well as the fingers need to Read more
Sunnah Method Of Gargling The Mouth In Ghusl
Question Must water be gargled to the back of the mouth/beginning of the throat or is it only necessary that Read more
Darul Ifta - Darul Uloom Azaadville - Madrasah Arabia Islamia