• +27 11 413 2785/6

Partnership Dispute

Question

A person decides to buy something and he does not want to buy it alone. He makes a general announcement that whoever wishes to join in the purchase may do so. Two or three people join  in the purchase of the item. Thereafter, due to some disagreement, the two who joined in the purchase stopped using the item because the initial buyer prevented them from using it.

1. Do they still have ownership in the item?
2. Can they demand their money?
3. If it correct that the initial buyer prevent them from using the item? 

Answer

1. The people who collectively purchased the item will be entitled to their share in it, as this scenario is an example of Shirkat-E-Amlaak. Merely not using the item will not disqualify their ownership.

2. They may not demand their money back. If they do, they would be forcing him to buy their shares in the item, whereas the consent of all parties is a condition for this transaction to be correct. “Person A” may either allow the others to benefit from the item, or he should buy their shares with full consent and approval of everyone involved.

3. It is not correct for him to stop the others from using the item. If he does stop them, he will be regarded as a Ghaasib. Just as he has a right in the item, so too do the others, who collectively purchased it with him.

Checked and Approved By:

Mufti Muhammed Saeed Motara Saheb D.B.

References

تبيين الحقائق ج٣ ص٣١٣ المكتبة الامدادية
الدر المختار مع رد المحتار ج٤ ص٣٠٠ سعيد
شرح مجلة الاحكام لعلي حيدردار الكتب العلمية ج١٠ ص٢٠ مادة ١٠٧٢
(الجوهرة النيرة المكتبة الامدادية ج1 ص٢٢٥)
(رد المحتار سعيد ج4 ص٥٠٥)
(البحر الرائق المكتبة الماجدية ج5 ص٢٦١)

Related Fatawa
A Share Of Profit For A Non-Partner

Question Two people invest in a company. They are 50/50 shareholders/owners. Both partners approach Zaid and tell him that you Read more

The Capital Contribution Percentage Being Different To The Profit-Share Percentage

Question Two people invest in a business. One gives 60 percent of the capital and one gives 40 . They Read more

Cash And Kind Capital Contributions In A Partnership

Question Amar wants to start a partnership with Zaid, he says that I will provide the machinery and you should Read more

Selling A Share In A Partnership Without Informing The Partner

Question Can one partner sell his share in a business without the consent of the other partner? Answer In principle, Read more

Liability Of Expense Due To Exiting A Partnership

Question Six brothers are in partnership in a portfolio of various properties. One of the brothers would like to exit. Read more

Darul Ifta - Darul Uloom Azaadville - Madrasah Arabia Islamia